Insurance coverage dilemma - urgent, advice greatly appreciated!

Hi everyone,

I was all set to pull the trigger on insurance. I ultimately went through Candace Fiscus, an insurance broker, because she seemed to truly understand how to correctly describe my services to the underwriters so I'd be categorized and covered appropriately. I got a quote through Lloyd's of London for professional liability and cyber & privacy, and although it wasn't the cheapest option, I felt it was the only quote I got that actually covered me correctly for patient advocacy work. Previously, another broker compared multiple insurers, including Biberg, and gave me quotes for Coterie and Hiscox, but they weren't accurate.

All of that to say, there is one big issue I found in my final review: insurance and billing advocacy was excluded from coverage. I would not be permitted to do basic bill reconciliation, even calling clients' insurance companies and the billing departments of clients' service providers to make sure claims have been submitted and bills reflect patient responsibility on EOBs. I was told that «coverage for insurance billing is not available under the patient advocacy class of business» and that I would have to independently "pursue a quote under the medical billing classification" from a different insurer, though she's not aware of any markets that provide this. 

Has anyone else ran into this issue, and if so, what solutions did you find? I'd very much appreciate any advice.

1 like
220 views
Victoria Victoria Killian 24 days ago
I ran into an issue initially but was told by an insurance broker through my local SBDC that services I was providing would be classified as “secretary” or maybe “consulting”.

I have insurance through BiBerk for professional and general liability with cyber security and marketing coverage. I am classified as “secretarial services”. I even called again this year and told them about my updated job duties and they stated I was still under the correct class. I pay a little over $700 for the year.
AnnMarie AnnMarie Cross 23 days ago
What Victoria shared is what we've heard over and over in the Facebook group.
Rachel L Rachel L Vaughters 23 days ago
I’m not a billing Advocate anymore, but for the past six years, I have used Hiscox Insurance for Errors & Omissions and Business liability insurance. $1 million/$2 million coverage & believe each policy is about $500 a year. At the recent Patient Advocate conference, I went to in MA, I spoke with a few Advocate that don’t have both they just carry errors & omissions insurance. I will probably review my policies.
Bonnie Bonnie Sheeren 23 days ago
I pay for E&O + business, because I do spend a great deal of time with in-person work & the business plan covers me from when I leave my home office. I don’t think remote advocates would need the business plan. I pay $750 for both @$62.50/ month. My agent is Jerry Becerra with Barbary Insurance in SF, CA.
amctest amctest amctest 21 day ago
thanksso much for sharing!
AnnMarie AnnMarie Cross 21 day ago
Thank you!
Erica Erica Bersin, BCPA, CPL 23 days ago
I've had a business for nearly 10 years and I carry $2m/$1m and living in the NYC market your head would explode re: my yearly premium. These are great rates!
Jeff Jeff Byars 23 days ago
It sounds to me like this exclusion would be if you were doing the billing for a physicians office or other healthcare provider. I would seek clarification to make sure they don't think you are actually doing medical billing.

BiBerk has me listed as Healthcare Management Social Services. My rate is based on my annual exposure, which is based on my annual revenue.
AnnMarie AnnMarie Cross 22 days ago
Thanks so much forsharing, jeff! that suggestion makes so much sense.
Kimberlie Kimberlie Williams-Feth, BSW 19 days ago
I think I have that same listing with Biberk, also.
Rebecca Rebecca Share-Howard 21 day ago
Hi, I appreciate everyone sharing their information and knowledge. There seems to be a great variety of classifications patient advocates fall under. I'm moving forward, thank you all!
Avrom Avrom Fox 20 days ago
if you have an MSW, you can get insurance through HPSO for a ridiculously low premium
Vickie Vickie Stoll 18 days ago
I recently had a request to be a Healthcare Surrogate for a couple, I reached out to my insurance company NEXT to find out if this was covered under my policy, and was told no and that they don’t have an option to offer me. I am located in Florida, please advise what which insurance company you use.
AnnMarie AnnMarie Cross 18 days ago
vickie,
good morning!
great timing.
there's another convo going no here RIGHT NOW about being a healthcare surrogate. that would be a GREAT group to ask about what insurance they carry!

the convo is here:

gnanow.org/community/medical-guidance/general-mg/317-when-patient-advocacy-meets-healthcare-surrogacy-healthcare-proxy-wh.html
Vickie Vickie Stoll 18 days ago
Thank you…
Nicole Nicole Rochester 17 days ago
As a health advocate who is also a physician, I (and other docs) have had many frustrating and sometimes confusing conversations with brokers regarding appropriate coverage. I agree that Candace Fiscus is one of the more knowledgeable brokers who seems to understand what we do. While I primarily do medical navigation, I have assisted with billing and insurance and have never thought I needed to adjust my policy coverage, so this conversation has been enlightening. I've been with Hiscox for years ($500/year for $1mil/$2mil) but I've had concerns for the last couple of years that the policy may be inadequate. I plan to explore other options, even though I realize they will likely have a higher premium.