When Patient Advocacy Meets Healthcare Surrogacy / Healthcare Proxy: Where Do We Draw the Line?
I'd love to start a conversation with fellow advocates about an important consideration in professional patient advocacy: serving as both an advocate and a legally designated healthcare decision-maker.
Through Peace of Mind Care Visits, I provide patient advocacy, healthcare navigation, and professional healthcare surrogacy services. These roles can complement one another, but they also come with distinct responsibilities and professional boundaries.
In Florida, we use the term Healthcare Surrogate, while other states may use Healthcare Proxy or Healthcare Agent. Although terminology and legal requirements vary, the underlying responsibility is similar: making authorized healthcare decisions on behalf of someone who cannot make those decisions themselves.
So how do we navigate providing both services to the same client?
My approach begins with clearly distinguishing the two roles.
While a client has decision-making capacity, my responsibility as an advocate is to educate, support, communicate, and help them navigate their healthcare options. The decisions remain theirs.
When a client lacks decision-making capacity and the legal requirements for exercising surrogate authority are met, my role changes. I may then be responsible for making healthcare decisions based on their known wishes, values, and applicable law.
I believe it's important to establish expectations early, document healthcare preferences, maintain clear professional boundaries, and recognize potential conflicts of interest.
But there are some interesting questions worth exploring.
How do we separate advocacy from surrogate decision-making when we're serving the same individual in both capacities? How do we handle disagreements with family members or healthcare providers? And what safeguards should we have in place to protect both the individual and the advocate?
I'd love to hear from other advocates:
Would you accept both roles for the same client? If you already provide healthcare surrogacy or healthcare proxy services, how do you structure those relationships, document decisions, and manage potential conflicts of interest?
I think this is an important conversation as professional advocacy continues to evolve, and I'd love to learn how others approach it.
Can you give any examples of concerns about conflict of interest?
In a surrogacy situation, the court likely still has some ability to hear concerns and issue findings. Which court? That probably varies from state to state. Developing or obtaining a document that potential surrogacy clients complete AND review with both you and any involved (or potentially involved) family members is key. Reviewing that document after any significant health changes and with some regularity is essential.
I plan to consult with my attorney on this before moving forward with accepting any surrogacy cases in which there is the possibility of family dispute. Heck — even the most basic families disagree over these kinds of issues. I might only accept surrogacy clients who are truly solo agers!
Thanks for opening this conversation!
Is there a need for a community room here specifically to talk about HCPOA/MPOA/Surrogacy and also guardianship?
I will gladly build one — take me 2 minutes.
My request would be that one or both of you informally 'lead' conversation in thsi area. bring topics to discuss. invite other advocates to give input. share key resources.
Perhaps it would also be a place that advocates who have questions about challenges tey are facing workign WITH (not as) POA/guardian could come to ask questions?
If you're at all interested, just let me know (here or message me or email me at help@gnanow.org) — i'll get a convo going and get it setup!
Regarding conflicts of interest, complicated family situations would certainly be a concern for me. I've discussed this with an attorney I work with, and I believe much of the risk can be addressed through careful planning before an urgent situation arises.
Ideally, the client and their attorney have already established legally executed documents, clearly documented healthcare and end-of-life preferences, and discussed how potential disagreements should be handled. Those documents provide the legal framework for guiding decisions when the client can no longer speak for themselves.
Another important consideration is serving as both an independent patient advocate and a professional healthcare surrogate. The Patient Advocate Certification Board addresses the importance of recognizing dual-role conflicts, and I believe separate written agreements, clearly defined responsibilities, and transparent billing are essential.
Other potential conflicts include financial incentives, referral relationships, family members who are paying for services, and situations where our personal beliefs differ from the client's expressed wishes.
That last one is particularly important to me. For example, imagine a client who specifically requests that certain family members not be notified of a serious medical event. Personally, I might struggle with that decision. However, before accepting the responsibility of serving as their healthcare surrogate, I would need to determine whether I could honor those wishes within the boundaries of the law and my designated authority.
I believe recognizing our own personal boundaries is just as important as understanding our professional responsibilities. If we cannot set aside our personal feelings and faithfully represent someone's wishes, we need to recognize that before agreeing to serve.
I would also consult with a trusted attorney before accepting a case involving significant family conflict.
I think these are important conversations for our profession as more advocates consider professional healthcare surrogacy.
Given your experience as a public guardian, I'm curious whether you've encountered situations where your personal beliefs differed from the individual's expressed wishes. How did you navigate those situations while maintaining your professional responsibilities?
I'd love to hear your perspective, along with any additional safeguards or conflicts you think we should be considering. I believe we can all learn from one another's experiences.
Thank you again for contributing to this discussion!
The circumstance of a family member paying for your services but disagreeing with the client's wishes is a concern, but one I would address up front when entering into the contracted services. Regardless of who pays the bill, the patient is my client. If the family is not okay with that, I am not the right advocate for them — and that's 100% okay.
The remaining concerns you cited seem to be potential ethical conflicts for us as advocates/surrogates. As a social worker, I have supported many (MANY) clients through situations and choices that were not aligned with my own beliefs. I wish I could offer some words of wisdom other than to say that you have to know where your red lines are. I know mine — and they are bright red!
I served as guardian for many adults who set ground rules about contact with or notification of their loved ones. Because I was court-ordered to make decisions in their best interest, I documented these requests very clearly and also told them when I would and would not be able to honor them. In a case of an advocacy client, that client (or the family member paying for advocacy services) could then have the option to choose a different advocate if they were uncomfortable with my position.
The simplest answer is that your first obligation is to yourself personally. Requests that make you question whether you would be able to sleep at night (look yourself in the mirror, require an additional trip to the confessional, etc.) are ones that merit deep consideration with a mentor, an attorney, and/or your clergy of choice.
I act as Health Care Proxy for many patients who live alone, and/or for families who for their own personal reasons prefer and outside entity handling their affairs. I am currently working on some intense cases. I believe there is a high demand for these services. In addition, many are losing faith in our health care system as a whole, so I see the role gaining traction in the future. Hope this helps!, Sharon
A GNA requirement is that, if an advocate offers services IN ADDITION to independent patient advocacy, the advocate MUST have a separate contract for those other services.
Some examples:
HCPOAs
flight nurses (This one is fascinating. I know a flight nurse who acts as the client's advocate UNTIL they get on her plane; then she's the flight nurse; at the tiertiary center she's advocate again; then flight nurse coming home, then advocate making sure all the continuity of care actually happens.)
medication management services
home health services such as phlebotomy, mobile IV, remote nursing
Thank you, Alison, for starting this important conversation, and everyone for sharing your perspectives. This is my two cents!
I previously worked in a guardianship office and served as an authorized agent and healthcare proxy, but not in both capacities for the same person. In the cases I handled, guardianship typically superseded healthcare proxy authority. I had a few that were limited guardianship and a family member was the healthcare surrogate/proxy — that was interesting.
In my advocacy work, I value establishing expectations early, documenting the client’s wishes, and being clear about whom I represent, regardless of who pays for services. I appreciate the points raised about separate agreements, clearly defined role transitions, and addressing potential conflicts before a crisis occurs. We are not going to please everyone. There is a reason you/me/us are appointed, selected, and retained instead of a family member.
Gathering information from and collaborating with family, when appropriate and consistent with the client’s wishes, can be critical to understanding the client’s history, behaviors, beliefs, and values—especially when the client has difficulty recalling or communicating their history. I see that input as valuable context, not a replacement for the client’s voice.
When a client does not want a family member involved, I believe it is important to understand the reason and document their wishes clearly. In my experience, the family member did not always agree, but securing their approval was not my role. My responsibility was to honor the client’s wishes within the limits of my authority. These situations are delicate and require compassion without losing sight of whom we serve.
I would approach accepting both roles cautiously, with legal guidance and a plan for managing disagreements. Knowing our own boundaries is equally important.
I know everyone is busy, but if you’re interested in a supportive space to share ideas, talk through challenges, or collaborate, keep me in mind. I’d be happy to facilitate a Zoom gathering.
Thank you all for the work you do to protect, serve and honor the wishes of those who are vulnerable.
I also completely agree about keeping services separate. I use two separate contracts for my independent patient advocacy and professional healthcare surrogate services. I think that distinction is important for clearly defining responsibilities, expectations, and professional boundaries.
nahac.com/current-events-calendar