Has anyone else found these things in a medical record? ...
I was reviewing records for a client’s bill and found something I hadn’t seen spelled out so clearly before: the physician’s order said patient to stay inpatient for another 36-48 hours, but the discharge timing was driven by an algorithm in direct contradiction to the doctor’s order. The patient went home 9 hours after the algorithm popped into the medical record.
Additionally, I found a notation from the medical billing department that they were using a specific DRG code (that means inpatient status) indicating they were expecting an insurance payment of $8K. But then the hospital billed it as outpatient.
I had to go through the normal channels and then take it to Compliance and finally Risk Management. They listened, and my patient's bill went away within hours of that phone call.
I'm curious:
Have you seen an algorithm or automated tool override a physician's judgment in the record? If so, how did you utilize that to get what you're client needed?
If so, where in the chart did you find it?
Has Compliance or Risk Management been more responsive to you than billing or patient financial services?
Now, I have seen a utilization reviewer by the hospital review the patients chart and if the patient didn’t meet inpatient criteria and insurance wouldn’t pay for further hospitalization, the care team had to figure out either 1) how to get the patient to meet criteria to keep them hospitalized, or 2) the care team, case management especially, has to scramble and get the needed services obtained outpatient.
Unfortunately, insurance can and does override physician judgement if “criteria” isn’t met. It has been a problem for years now and is only getting worse.
Here are some tips to delaying dicharge:
You can postpone a hospital discharge and extend your Medicare coverage by requesting an expedited fast appeal through your local Quality Improvement Organization (QIO).
How to Postpone Your Discharge
• Review the Notice: Look for the written form called «An Important Message from Medicare about Your Rights» (IM) given to you by the hospital. This notice explains your rights and lists the contact information for your state's QIO.
• Contact the QIO Immediately: Call your local Beneficiary and Family-Centered Care Quality Improvement Organization (BFCC-QIO) by midnight on the day of your scheduled discharge to trigger a fast appeal while you are still in the hospital. You can find your regional QIO contact via the Official Medicare Fast Appeals Portal.
• Stay in the Hospital Free of Charge: once you apply through this schedule
Hope that helps.
I have been able to utilize this process successfully many times.
Karen Mercereau, RN, iRNPA
I cannot say whether an algorithm was involved in his case, but the experience reinforced for me how important it is to compare the clinical documentation with the billing and ask questions when something does not line up.
Your persistence—and willingness to take the concern beyond billing—made a meaningful difference for your client. I would be interested to know where you found the automated recommendation in the chart and whether you received a written explanation of the discrepancy, in addition to having the bill removed.
Observation status is outpatient by definition—the patient is being monitored to decide whether to discharge or admit. A patient cannot remain both observation and inpatient. Status can be changed from observation to inpatient if criteria are met; that determination is made by the physician in conjunction with utilization review. Inpatient is generally paid by DRG; observation is outpatient and paid under the outpatient payment system.
I also haven’t seen chart notes that reference an algorithm overriding the attending’s judgment. In my experience, the attending and utilization review carefully review patient class for appropriateness. When there has been a clear discrepancy between the physician’s documented assessment and the status that was applied, Compliance and Risk Management have been more responsive than Patient Financial Services. For Medicare patients, the Important Message from Medicare and QIO fast appeal remain useful options to pause discharge while those issues are addressed.
I believe I replied to you directly. This depends on the hospital systems and the unit. Some are more supportive than others. I can tell you the client contracted with you on the backend, which is unfortunate. Glad you got it resolved. Karen is right below. There are key terms and ways to manage the push towards discharge. There were probably key things that needed to be done that the computer didn't account for, which would have made this an unsafe discharge.