Thank you for sharing this. Your experience resonated with me because I recently questioned discrepancies between my dad’s medical records and the bill he received. After raising those questions, we received a letter stating that his out-of-pocket expense had been addressed internally and that he did not have to pay.
I cannot say whether an algorithm was involved in his case, but the experience reinforced for me how important it is to compare the clinical documentation with the billing and ask questions when something does not line up.
Your persistence—and willingness to take the concern beyond billing—made a meaningful difference for your client. I would be interested to know where you found the automated recommendation in the chart and whether you received a written explanation of the discrepancy, in addition to having the bill removed.
Just a reminder: “Many are called, but few are chosen.”
Thank you, Alison, for starting this important conversation, and everyone for sharing your perspectives. This is my two cents!
I previously worked in a guardianship office and served as an authorized agent and healthcare proxy, but not in both capacities for the same person. In the cases I handled, guardianship typically superseded healthcare proxy authority. I had a few that were limited guardianship and a family member was the healthcare surrogate/proxy — that was interesting.
In my advocacy work, I value establishing expectations early, documenting the client’s wishes, and being clear about whom I represent, regardless of who pays for services. I appreciate the points raised about separate agreements, clearly defined role transitions, and addressing potential conflicts before a crisis occurs. We are not going to please everyone. There is a reason you/me/us are appointed, selected, and retained instead of a family member.
Gathering information from and collaborating with family, when appropriate and consistent with the client’s wishes, can be critical to understanding the client’s history, behaviors, beliefs, and values—especially when the client has difficulty recalling or communicating their history. I see that input as valuable context, not a replacement for the client’s voice.
When a client does not want a family member involved, I believe it is important to understand the reason and document their wishes clearly. In my experience, the family member did not always agree, but securing their approval was not my role. My responsibility was to honor the client’s wishes within the limits of my authority. These situations are delicate and require compassion without losing sight of whom we serve.
I would approach accepting both roles cautiously, with legal guidance and a plan for managing disagreements. Knowing our own boundaries is equally important.
I know everyone is busy, but if you’re interested in a supportive space to share ideas, talk through challenges, or collaborate, keep me in mind. I’d be happy to facilitate a Zoom gathering.
Thank you all for the work you do to protect, serve and honor the wishes of those who are vulnerable.
I cannot say whether an algorithm was involved in his case, but the experience reinforced for me how important it is to compare the clinical documentation with the billing and ask questions when something does not line up.
Your persistence—and willingness to take the concern beyond billing—made a meaningful difference for your client. I would be interested to know where you found the automated recommendation in the chart and whether you received a written explanation of the discrepancy, in addition to having the bill removed.
Thank you, Alison, for starting this important conversation, and everyone for sharing your perspectives. This is my two cents!
I previously worked in a guardianship office and served as an authorized agent and healthcare proxy, but not in both capacities for the same person. In the cases I handled, guardianship typically superseded healthcare proxy authority. I had a few that were limited guardianship and a family member was the healthcare surrogate/proxy — that was interesting.
In my advocacy work, I value establishing expectations early, documenting the client’s wishes, and being clear about whom I represent, regardless of who pays for services. I appreciate the points raised about separate agreements, clearly defined role transitions, and addressing potential conflicts before a crisis occurs. We are not going to please everyone. There is a reason you/me/us are appointed, selected, and retained instead of a family member.
Gathering information from and collaborating with family, when appropriate and consistent with the client’s wishes, can be critical to understanding the client’s history, behaviors, beliefs, and values—especially when the client has difficulty recalling or communicating their history. I see that input as valuable context, not a replacement for the client’s voice.
When a client does not want a family member involved, I believe it is important to understand the reason and document their wishes clearly. In my experience, the family member did not always agree, but securing their approval was not my role. My responsibility was to honor the client’s wishes within the limits of my authority. These situations are delicate and require compassion without losing sight of whom we serve.
I would approach accepting both roles cautiously, with legal guidance and a plan for managing disagreements. Knowing our own boundaries is equally important.
I know everyone is busy, but if you’re interested in a supportive space to share ideas, talk through challenges, or collaborate, keep me in mind. I’d be happy to facilitate a Zoom gathering.
Thank you all for the work you do to protect, serve and honor the wishes of those who are vulnerable.